Return to Sender - Trailer

Miranda Wells, a nurse living in a small town, has a nice life. She is about to become a surgical nurse and is buying a new house. She's single and one of her friends sets her up on a blind date with a man named Kevin. On the day of the date, Miranda hears someone outside on the porch. She opens the door and finds, who she assumes is Kevin standing there, and invites him in. He walks to the door and locks it. He then attacks and rapes her. The police identify the man and arrest the rapist, William Finn. Miranda befriends William in prison with her letters. He apologizes for what he did to her. When he is released, William sends Miranda flowers and makes plans to visit her. When he arrives at her home she poisons him with antifreeze in his lemonade and straps him to a bed in the basement. Over the next few hours she amputates his left hand, taunting him with it and saying that she knows what's most important to him. The viewer is left to guess if she also amputated his penis.